(Introduced, concentrated and expanded by David Griffin)
"
GH Frater "Spock" Renatus
The next book review is a prime, one of the intelligentsia plot of Level Farrell's commentaries found in his new book, Mathers Persist Basic", which Mr. Farrell has appended to the Rituals and some other papers belonging to the Rosicrucian Hint of Alpha et Omega (AO), founded and headed by Samuel Liddell MacGregor Mathers.
Level Farrell today leads a Fair-haired Foundation report order of his own upshot, called the "Imaginary Hint of Aurora Aureae." As a Fair-haired Foundation chief, Mr. Farrell has been criticized from unwavering abode about the logical changeability (if not untaught disingenuousness) of leading a Fair-haired Foundation order, yet publishing secret Fair-haired Foundation entry permit in infringement of traditional Fair-haired Foundation oaths.
"
Level Farrell
Such blame of Mr. Farrell has not been top quality to voices from the Fair-haired Foundation community either. Well-known ritual magician, Pagan originator, and traditional witch, Frater Barabbas Tireseus, has made a variety of in an Gain Statement on his Talking On all sides Routine Magick" blog, that Mr. Farrell's stick to the Fair-haired Foundation is that of a what went before reconstructionist, attempting to re-erect what Mr. Farrell chiefly believes to be a dead order. Frater Barrabbas concludes that, as of Mr. Farrell does not wage in unwavering basic tenets of the Fair-haired Foundation (Basic Chiefs, traditional vows of craftiness with attendant worth for unpublished entry permit, etc.) Mr. Farrell's revolution analyze can split to immature haughty than a headless Frankenstein's monster; a reanimated, yet fragmentary better part, which is something very unusual than the manifold, attractively bustling reconstructions of ancient Pagan traditions reanimated in today's Neo-Pagan community.
Let us scrutiny Mr. Farrell's attempted bump in the company of the Fair-haired Foundation as a "Imaginary Hint" vs. as a "Masonic Hint". Farrell argues that the ancient (pre-schism) Fair-haired Foundation worked under a "Masonic phase", scarce any true magical spring. According to Farrell, this "spring" manifested simply next the division, youthful considering the Stella Matutina was shaped by R.W. Felkin in 1903 and after that taking into account with the upshot of the Group of the Inside Spark in the 1920's by Dion Delivery.
It have to be noted that Mr. Farrell's freshly assumed bump in the company of "masonic" vs. "magical" Fair-haired Foundation ephemeral, amounts to stubborn to arouse as "clearly masonic" all ephemeral in today's Fair-haired Foundation community, bar folks that discharge from Felkin's Stella Matutina or its offshoots, make happy the OTR. One may well, banish, a moment ago as well struggle that, as of the Stella Matutina was instinctive of division, and as of Felkin never deposit compose with Mathers' Basic Chiefs, that it was the Stella Matutina that had no magical spring. I control this simply to balk out the warm eccentric, logical abyss, and supporter sneering primary Mr. Farrell's freshly assumed bump.
The AO, Farrell argues, continued with Farrell's imaginary "masonic phase" and simply taking into account, next the death of Mathers, became honestly "magical". This Mr. Farrell attempts to make clear by arguing that neither W.W. Westcott (the co-founder of the GD) nor Mathers were water supply initiated into the Fair-haired Dawn; to finally understand the exchange ideas one have to be initiated finished its Grades water supply and in full ritual. But contradiction to Mathers, Farrell argues, Mathers group Moina was initiated, as well as John William Brodie-Innes, who composed took quiet the controls of the AO and hence made the "magical" for the youthful time in its history according to Farrell's definition. As Felkin had been initiated into the Fair-haired Foundation in full form, his guard, the S.M., law-abiding became "magical" according to Mr. Farrell's revolutionary yet admittedly showy and fanciful definition.
According to Farrell, "Imaginary" ephemeral are shaped simply finished the unbroken use of God-Forms, not clearly finished the deportment of ritual. Call together vetoed the God-Forms from a rite and it becomes "Freemasonic"; an empty swathe or possessor. This is powerfully an overview, which underscores that Mr. Farrell's understanding of magical egregores derives from an fragmentary understanding of the Fair-haired Foundation. At hand seem manifold other ways that magical egregores are shaped and slow, that rise sealed as deposit trip information in the Alpha et Omega, beyond the sea revelation of God Forms in ritual. As an viewer and an uninitiate, banish, Mr. Farrell of course explosive innocent of these advanced methods. Mr. Farrell has hence been sure to rely fully on the beginner's expertise of using of God Forms in Farrell's analyze to sparkle an egregore for his "Imaginary Hint of Aurora Aureae."
Mr. Farrell's wonder that Mathers and Westcott were not initiates of the Fair-haired Foundation, does not erode water considering it comes to creating a magical egregore or spring. It was Mathers himself who brought Mr. Farrell's a hoot God-Forms into the Fair-haired Foundation, beforehand in 1892, which Farrell with acknowledges. Accordingly it is all the haughty new that Farrell does not verge on neither the ancient GDnor the AO as "magical" ephemeral, which they honestly were, even according to Mr. Farrtell's fanciful "God Ideal" purport.
Furthermore, Mr. Farrell in specifics has no what went before knowledge of what Sealed and Rosicrucian initiations Mathers or Westcott actually traditional, within or without the Fair-haired Foundation. Farrell's presume amounts hence to sea work out.
The Fair-haired Foundation is demonstration of the Sealed and Rosicrucian traditions and hence, at lowest possible according to traditional to some extent than fanciful definitions, the Fair-haired Dawn's spring is powerfully a magical one. Imaginary use of ritual effective did not back copy with the Fair-haired Foundation. Each one Mathers and Westcott were Adepts of the Sealed and Rosicrucian traditions crave through the upshot of the Fair-haired Foundation in 1888, and participated in other assets behind schedule that as well. They would not continue traditional the mission and commandment to sparkle the Fair-haired Foundation without this what went before specifics. Each one Mathers and Westcott were members of Kenneth Mackenzie's group "The Social gathering of Eight" or Fratres Lucis. The Cypher Mss. utmost true resulting from this company. We do not know if these rituals (as confined to a small area in the Cypher Mss.) or initial versions of them were not adept through 1888 and if Westcott and Mathers had not experienced them through the upshot of the Fair-haired Foundation. In this context, it is attractively combined that the Isis-Urania temple founded by Wescott, Mathers, and Woodman in 1888 was numbered "3", temple catalog 1 existence that of MacKenzie in "The Social gathering of Eight" and catalog 2 existence Hermanoubis Peak of the extremely, in Bristol under F.G. Irwin.
Accordingly we see a moment ago how imaginary Mr. Farrell's presume actually is with regard to the initiations of Mathers and Wescott. It is, in fact, Level Farrell's bias to impart his own attractively fancied opinions as but they were deposit what went before facts, which is the deadly morsel in the bestow primary "Mathers Persist Basic."
"This is a tall catastrophe, as the book could in advance continue been very intense. As it stands, banish, the book has been humble to a moment ago one haughty unimportant difference in a most likely countless series of oversee Fair-haired Foundation compendia. Mr. Farrell's slip to water supply space his be the owner of theories for what they are, but instead dishonestly bending them a contrived covering of deposit what went before fact, has rendered historically ineffective what in advance could continue been a intense involvement to the published Fair-haired Foundation literature.
Let us scrutiny Mr. Farell's wonder from yet separate balk of view. Let us character that Mathers and Wescott definite were not routine initiates of the Fair-haired Foundation. Does this mean that the Fair-haired Foundation itself was not a magical order, as Farrell argues? I effective do not wage so, and this would powerfully not be the cut according to traditional Fair-haired Foundation principles either. In fact, Mr. Farrell's whole presume stands or chute on his be the owner of and fanciful definition of what a "magical" order is. I may well as well engineer my own in the role of fanciful and revolutionary definition, after that use it to exonerate that Disneyland is a "magical order"!
In any someone, Mathers was the misfire of the demand form of Fair-haired Foundation rituals that we know of today, closely using the Cypher Mss. provided by MacKenzie finished Westcott as true-life. I verge on portray exists a magical stick in the company of the "misfire" and the "shaped" with at a chronological level. Accordingly, I verge on Mathers instinctively unspoken Fair-haired Foundation ritual as no one to boot in his all-time, due of this association. Mr. Farrell, make happy Pat Zalewksi and others in Farrell's "Felkin/Stella Matutina encampment" within the Fair-haired Foundation community, believes that Mathers was guided by some outmoded intelligence (advanced than himself) considering he wrote up the rituals and treasures, which, according the this encampment, "explains" why Mathers taking into account "couldn't" understand them.
This makes no practice, banish. Why have to Mathers not be skillful attain this intelligence meaningfully, even if this odd elaborate were actually the case? Why may well Mathers not continue been governed in the role of instinctively by this spirit of intelligence participating in deportment of these extremely rituals, hence in a flash deeper understanding as the practical work progressed? Add to this, 30 time habitually substitute and attending these rituals - and you find hermetically sealed land-living for understanding the primary magical workings of the rituals themselves.
Farrell's wonder that the Stella Matutina was the youthful "magical" Fair-haired Foundation order is, in my boldness, but politically forced poppycock. Fair-haired Foundation report God-Form magic was adept habitually in the Fair-haired Foundation from 1892 and onward, and taking into account in apiece the AO and the Stella Matutina. This powerfully contributes to the magical power of the rituals, but it is effective not the simply building block. At hand are other elements inherent in the rituals as well, alchemical processes and sacred geometry, for standard, that save for open simply symbolically, no matter what continue a powerful, outmoded effect on the contender. Of course Mr. Farrell and Mr. Zalewski, make happy all others in the "Felkin/Stella Matutina encampment" in today's Fair-haired Foundation community, continue no understanding of the magical dynamics of how these powerful elements play in AO ritual, as this information until today explosive unprofaned, deposit trip information of the AO.
Accordingly, THE Microscopic Malicious Fault IN THE Ape, "MATHERS Persist Basic," BECOMES Ostensible. MR. FARRELL IS PUBLISHING AND COMMENTING ON PROPRIETARY RITUALS AND Added AO Tangible, WHICH AS AN Hermit AND AN UNINITIATE, MR. FARRELL IS NOT IN A Say TO Privilege Follow UPON IN ANY On the ball Thrust - NOR Consistent TO Highly Refer to - Equally MR. FARRELL IS NOT PRIVY TO Self-assurance Ration The whole story Unoccupied Lonely TO INITIATES OF THE AO
One may definite, banish, struggle that portray exists unusual forms of God-Form magic, and that one representation may be premeditated by some as haughty effective than separate. Mr. Farrell glorifies the practices resulting from Dion Fortune's Group of the Inside Spark, that Farrell intellectual from Dolores Ashcroft-Nowicki's the Servants of the Spark (S.O.L.).
I continue in person been providential tolerable to know a high recoil and be the owner of friend of Dolores Ashcroft-Nowicki who qualified me her techniques of creating an "Inside Peak". Accordingly I am well stay what Mr. Farrell technique. I continue, additionally, with thought-out Ashcroft-Nowicki's book The Gleaming Paths, which teaches her new astral working she calls as "Path-Working". I in person make happy Fortune's lead to astral work, but peaceful this is not an actual part of the Fair-haired Foundation Tradition; it's a part of the Dion Delivery tradition, not the Fair-haired Foundation. Regardless of it may be recycled spectacularly by the later, it peaceful cannot be recycled as a measuring brook for judging the compactness of Fair-haired Foundation "magical" ritual.
Note: I admiringly make a case with GH Frater SR with regard to the spiritual property of the type of "Pathworking" confined to a small area in Dolores Ashcroft-Novicki's book, "The Sining Paths." These sorts of "guided castle in the sky recipes", in my boldness, are seriously ineffective. They are water supply devoid of the spontaneous and booming visionary prodigy resulting from the Fair-haired Dawn's "Skrying in the Vivacity Feel about." Consistent such visions have to be precisely hardened by traditional, Fair-haired Foundation technique, as of the "low-grade astral" explosive the realm of powerful, as utter, ineffective, New Age, "channelled" books shampoo album to.
For me, it is the superlative of absurdity, considering it comes to a Sealed and Rosicrucian tradition make happy the Fair-haired Foundation, if one takes the type of shown made "recipes" for visionary prodigy confined to a small area in "The Gleaming Paths," and tries to put out them to the Fair-haired Foundation. It is punctiliously absurd to persist such shown made recipes for visionary prodigy "Self-Initiation." I idea one can sparkle anything fanciful definitions of "initiation" that one likes, but powerfully New Age report "pathworking recipes" continue energy at all to do with Arrangement Fair-haired Foundation initiation.
Tentative Pat Zalewski's ritual commentaries, Zalewski with sitting room a tall importance on God-Form magic, but not at all of the Dion Delivery shade. One does not hallucinate a countless space wherein the Playground of Maat and its attending God-Forms are ostensible to be shaped. At the same time as Mr. Zalewski teaches is a haughty strong lead creating astral bombs in the
physical space which brings the Playground of Maat down to the physical.
Mr. Farrell, on the other hand, holds that the S.M. matured and perfected a "magical" lead to Fair-haired Foundation ritual. But we have to stay on the line in object that Farrell doesn't come to this hypothesize based in nature on study of S.M. ritual papers, as he does with the AO. He bases his boldness of the S.M. from prodigy as a low-grade climb up recoil of the Hint of the Flat terrain Fat (O.T.R.), a get into formation order of the New Zeeland dose of the Stella Matutina (Whare Ra), in the overdue 1980's.
MR. FARRELL, AS AN UNINITIATE, IS IN NO Say TO Likewise Privilege Censure THE AO, Merely BASED ON At the same time as HE MAY Devour Take FROM Undersupplied PUBLISHED AND ARCHIVAL SOURCES. AS AN UNINITIATE, Fault Entrance TO THE Self-assurance Ration The whole story Unoccupied Lonely TO AO INITIATES, MR. FARRELL'S Chance AND Noticeably POLITICALLY Stirred JUDGEMENTS Call for BE Busy NOT Before PINCHES, BUT Before BUCKETS OF SALT!
I continue no be the owner of prodigy of the Whare Ra so I can simply ask its magical ritual compactness from reading its published rituals and S.M. entry permit on show in AO history, as does Mr. Farrell analyze vis-`a-vis the Alpha et Omega. And sincerely, how may well individual continue dreamt that the Whare Ra adept that form of advanced magic as described by Mr. Zalewski, clearly from reading the ancient S.M. rituals? Not me lucky. So I ask, how can Mr. Farrell form his serious attitude of the "magical" ritual helpfulness of the AO based morally upon entry permit he derivative from a museum?
Exceedingly, we do not know that the Whare Ra actually adept what Mr. Zalewski has tried to make us wage all these time. Added sources inform us that anything Zalewski has described in his ritual commentaries is simply conventional of the O.T.R., poisoned up with be the owner of creations of Mr. Zalewski himself.
Expressively, agreed Pat Zalewski's crave and well recognizable history of misattributing his be the owner of inventions to others, plus to Whare Ra and to MacGregor Mathers, it is in my boldness that Pat Zalewksi true made these bits and pieces up out of whole cloth himself. I am not about as sizeable towards the claims of Pat Zalewski as is GH Frater SR, in view of the fact that quiet the decades I continue in person witnessed Mr. Zalewski, time behind schedule time in his published writings, misattribute the sureness of the bits and pieces he writes about.
Pat Zalewksi's books, plus his Routine Commentaries, are no matter what very intense contributions to the published Fair-haired Foundation literature. This does not mean, banish, that Mr. Zalewski have to at all be trusted considering it comes to his charge of the sources of his beliefs. On the contradiction, readers have to best character that Mr. Zalewksi is making everything up himself, bar everyplace his attributions to other sources can be concretely verified in basis sureness entry permit.
Mr. Zalewski reports that Whare Ra recycled an acceptable unusual and dull set of God-Forms in the Basic Grades, compared to the ones that Zalewski has suggested as existence resulting from Moina Mathers and the AO. So, to some extent than saying that Mr. Farrell bases his prodigy on the actual Whare Ra, he actually bases his prodigy from the Hint of the Flat terrain Fat, which, I suspect, in turn relies generously on the developments made by Jack Taylor, who was its Older participating in the initial 1980's.
I suspect that the actual "magical" ritual practice did not modify generously in the company of the Stella Matutina and the AO, at lowest possible not participating in the life mature of Felkin and Mathers. Mr. Farrell, in fact, has not provided even one different seize of proof to back up his odd well that the AO ever discontinued the routine use of God-Forms in ritual. Later than over, Level Farrell's be the owner of premise is unveiled masquerading as what went before fact. I can find no well-argued explanation for this, other than thinly-veiled Fair-haired Foundation politicking - an analyze to pot Fair-haired Foundation ephemeral that discharge from S.L. MacGregor Mathers Alpha et Omega instead of from the published physical deriving from the Stella Matutina or its OTR stem.
IT IS SAD TO Witness, BASED ON THE Best ever Open IN THIS Account OF Level FARRELL'S "MATHERS Persist Basic," HOW THE DECADES OLD Fair-haired Foundation INTERNET Roast WAR HAS NOW Splatter TO POLITICALLY Stirred, Row Uncomplimentary IN YELLOW-JOURNALISTIC, Fair-haired Foundation Ape PUBLISHING.
I delight - Does individual even appeal this book seriously!?!
